The New Kid Mother Goose disguises her loyal servant duck, Wilbur, as a rival superhero,"The Extermigator" and arranges for him to "foil" some fake robberies. If "The Extermigator" wins P-Town's "Citizens Against Crime Award", Wilbur can kidnap Mayor Matthews as he's awarded the gong and Mother Goose will take control of the town. Will Pet Squad discover that "The Extermigator" is a fake in time? It looks unlikely as Dodge's admiration for the new crime fighter runs so deep he's determined to join forces with "The Extermigator", even at the cost of splitting up Pet Squad for good.