The First Silver Sugar As Elliot rests in bed to recover from his wounds, he describes the attacker with Challe concluding him to be another warrior fairy who is attracted to silver sugar. Nine days later, the workshop creates its entry confection, a shining tree made of snowflake confections. The artisans sets off for Lewiston at sunset with the confection with Challe protecting them, and along the way they encounter the attacker. Challe stays behind to fight him while Anne and the artisans continue to travel, the mysterious fairy tells Challe he wants the sugar confections and a silver sugar master, Anne and the artisans arriving at Lewiston in the morning. The Paige workshop competes against the Radcliffe and Mercury workshops at the selection, and Anne notices the lack of shine in her workshop's confection that she saw back at the workshop. After requesting the judge to provide lighting, the confection shows off its shine and the Paige workshop is selected to make confections for the Holy Beginnings Festival. Afterwards, Elliot returns Challe's wing to Anne and tells her she has created the first silver sugar, which is silver sugar that never goes bitter, and she is free to leave whenever she wants. Anne decides to stay with the workshop through the end of the festival, while Challe tells Anne that the attacker got away, but swears to kill him the next time they meet.