The Red Fairy Lafalle wounds Orland that makes him unable to use his left eye, further putting the artisans behind schedule. With Bridget blaming herself for bringing the fairy into the castle that injured her childhood friend, Anne convinces her to think about what to do next. The other artisans continue their work as they re-grind the hardened silver sugar to make the confections. The next day, Noah agrees to help, while Elliot brings in Kat to uphold his part of the deal. Later in the day, Anne and Elliot return to Lewiston to meet the priest organizing the festival, and the priest presents an offer to Anne in which the Mercury Workshop takes over and the Paige Workshop will still get paid the reward. Anne declines, putting the workshop's reputation on the line. On the way out of Lewiston, Anne spots Jonas drunk on the street. Despite being cleared of any wrongdoing, Jonas has given up on being an artisan, but Anne convinces him to fill in for Orland and help make the confections for the festival. Back at the castle, Lafalle attacks again, threatening to kill Elliot unless Anne and Challe go along with him. Anne decides to go along with Lafalle's demand and hands him Challe's wing, they leave the castle as they now belonging to Lafalle.